Why a Super Bowl

Poor officiating is one of the most debated aspects of NFL Sundays, and Week 13 proved no different. The Washington Commanders saw a potential turning point slip away late in their Sunday Night Football matchup against the Denver Broncos.

While fans often drive these discussions, this time a Hall of Fame voice stepped into the conversation. His reaction added legitimacy to the complaint and sparked broader questions about how replay is used in today’s NFL.

Tony Dungy Calls Out Replay Process After Commanders Controversy

The non-call in question was a missed tripping penalty during a crucial fourth-quarter play in Washington’s loss on Nov. 30. Commanders quarterback Marcus Mariota was clearly affected by contact that caused his knee to hit the turf, which replay later confirmed. Officials spotted the ball where he went down, but did not assess a tripping foul by Broncos defender Dondrea Tillman that caused the fall.

If assessed, it would’ve been a 15-yard penalty on Denver and a fresh set of downs for Washington. Instead, the play resulted in a loss, shifting momentum back to the Broncos. For a Commanders team fighting to stay in the NFC Wild Card picture, a 30-yard swing felt like much more than a minor oversight.

Super Bowl-winning head coach Tony Dungy took issue with the inconsistency. His post on X was blunt in assessing the credibility problem created by the fact that specific missed calls are correctable through replay, while others are not.

The NFL continues to use replay to correct some calls but not to correct obvious missed calls. This creates a credibility problem. When replay is used to move the spot of a ball 6 inches or used to see if the QB’s knee touched the ground— but can’t be used to see if he was… pic.twitter.com/SfCQyVNlVJ

— Tony Dungy (@TonyDungy) December 1, 2025

“The NFL continues to use replay to correct some calls but not to correct obvious missed calls. This creates a credibility problem. When replay is used to move the spot of a ball 6 inches or used to see if the QB’s knee touched the ground — but can’t be used to see if he was tripped or can’t be used to see if the clock is at :00 when players are pointing to the clock it creates issues. We either need to correct ALL OBVIOUS missed calls or we need to let the officials call the games on the field and live with it.”

Dungy expanded on his point after a commenter called him a crybaby, arguing the issue was accountability, not emotion.

“Not crying. Just wondering why in the Broncos-Commanders game the officials didn’t see the QBs knee hit the ground. Replay technology saw his knee did hit the ground. It hit the ground because he was illegally tripped. So on the play we correct one missed call but not the other one. That cost Washington 30 yds. But that’s OK????”

MORE: Key Takeaways From Broncos-Commanders: Courtland Sutton Is Back

The NFL has tightened and reworked replay rules multiple times over the past decade, but controversies like this show the system still leaves gaps. When a Super Bowl champion coach says the process lacks consistency, the league often listens. Whether that leads to change before the postseason remains to be seen.